Subject: [sv-bc] email voting on Cliff's proposal - RESULTS
From: Srouji, Johny (johny.srouji@intel.com)
Date: Thu Jan 08 2004 - 05:25:05 PST
Hi All,
Following are the email voting results:
Agree:
Cliff Cummings
Matt Maidment
Mark Hartoog
Peter Flake
Doug Warmke
Francoise
Dave Rich
Nikhil Rishiyur
Stu Sutherland (does not have voting privileges at this
stage)
Oppose: none
Abstain: none
Decision: Proposal PASSES.
Cliff, can you please review the following comments sent by Dave and
Peter?
Following are comments sent by Dave Rich:
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
I did find one grammar correction needed in section 19,4,2
This interface example shows how to use modports to control signal
directions _restrict signal interface access and direction_ . It uses
the modport name in the module instantiation.
Should be
This interface example shows how to use modports to control signal
directions _restrict interface __ signal __access and control their
direction_ . It uses the modport name in the module instantiation.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Following are comments sent by Peter Flake:
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
I vote in favour of Cliff's proposal, but I have noticed that it would
be clearer if the following text and example were swapped, since the
text refers to the previous example.
REPLACE
module m (i2 i);
...
endmodule
module s (i2 i);
...
endmodule
module top;
i2 i();
m u1 (.i(i.master));
s u2 (.i(i.slave));
endmodule
The syntax of interface_name.modport_name reference_name gives a local
name for a hierarchical reference. Note that this can be generalized to
any interface with a given modport name by writing
interface.modport_name reference_name.
WITH
The syntax of interface_name.modport_name reference_name gives a local
name for a hierarchical reference. Note that this can be generalized to
any interface with a given modport name by writing
interface.modport_name reference_name.
module m (i2 i);
...
endmodule
module s (i2 i);
...
endmodule
module top;
i2 i();
m u1 (.i(i.master));
s u2 (.i(i.slave));
endmodule
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
--- Johny.
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b28 : Thu Jan 08 2004 - 05:26:17 PST