SV-EC Meeting Minutes 14 April 2003 11:00 am. Monday Voting Members (3/4 or >= 75%) (rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrxrxrrxrrrrrr) (-----a----aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa-) Arturo Salz (Synopsys) (-----aa-aaaaaaaaa-a--aaaaaa) Brad Pierce (Synopsys) (a-aaaa-aaa-aaaa-a-aa---a-aa) Cliff Cummings (IEEE 1364) (aaaaa-aaaa-aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa) David Smith (Synopsys) (---aaa-a-aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa) Francoise Martinolle (Cadence) (------------aaaaaaaa-aaaaaa) Jay Lawrence (Cadence) (-------------------a-aaaaa-) Jeff Freedman (ModelTech) (-------------------aaa-aaaa) Michael Burns (Motorola) (aaaapaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa-) Mehdi Mohtashemi (Synopsys) (-aaaaaaaa-aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa) Neil Korpusik (Sun) (-aaaaaaa-aaaaaa-aaaa-aaaaaa) Stefen Boyd (IEEE 1364) Non-Voting Members (attendance based) (----------------a------a---) Chris Spear (Synopsys) (-aaa-a-aaaa---a-aaaa-aaaa--) Dennis Brophy (ModelTech) (----------------a----a-----) Dave Rich (Synopsys) (--------aa-a-a-aaa-a--a-a--) Stu Sutherland (IEEE 1364) Guests (non-voting) (--a------------------------) Adam Krolnik (LSI Logic) (---a-a----------a----------) Alec Stanculescu (Fintronic) (----------------a----------) Alex Zamfirescu (ASC) (---------aa-a-aa-a-a-------) Don Mills (LCDM Engineering) (aa-aa----------------------) Heath Chambers (HMC) (aaa-aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa-aaaa) Kevin Cameron (National) (-----a-a-a-a---------------) Tim Corcoran (WHDL) Inactive Members (Missed last 4 meetings) (-aaa-----------------------) Dave Kelf (Synopsys) (----------------a----------) Jayant Nagda (Synopsys) (aaaaaaaaaaaa-------a-------) Karen Pieper (Synopsys) (---a-aa-----a--------------) Kurt Takara (0-in) (--a--a-a-------------------) Michael McNamara (Verisity) (aaa------------------------) Paul Graham (Cadence) (aapaa----------ma----a-----) Peter Flake (Synopsys) (a--------------------------) Roy Armoni (Intel) (aapa-a---------------a-----) Simon Davidmann (IEEE) (aa---a---------------------) Steven Sharp (Cadence) (-----a---------------------) Stephen Meier (Synopsys) (-aaaaa--a------------------) Tom Fitzpatrick (Synopsys) (-----a---------------------) Zeev Kirshenbaum (Verisity) r => Regular meeting x => Extra meeting (Presence counts for attendance, absence does not) a => Attended p => Attended by proxy - => Missed Action Items: [identified with AI (#) in this text, # refers to AI number] 1. David: : Start issue list for 3.2 2. David: LRM-15 11.22: Raise issue of order dependence between static int and int static with BC. 3. David: 3.9: Add issue to 3.2 to clarify passing event type through port Minutes 4/14/03 taken by David Smith 1. Approve the minutes of 7 April 2003 Motion to approve: Michael Second: Brad Abstain: Neil, Jay Against: Cliff Minutes approved 2. Discussion on last weeks review process. The discussion centered on the lack of community review of issues in the process. We discussed the problems due to the short turn-around time and the amount of questions, issues, and changes that were generated. Francoise suggested that a spread sheet be sent to each of the reviewers asking them to submit those items which they felt are not closed so that we can track them in future effort. This has been done. Jay pointed out that the time for any significant changes in the LRM is past and the only issues that should be addressed are ones that would keep the reviewer from voting on sending the LRM to the board. A mechanism was developed to support this. We all agreed that the shortening of the time period to roughly a week was unfortunate. 3. Schedule for Draft 5 and Board review. The Draft 5 LRM is planned to be available this week. We will hold a meeting on Monday to discuss any issues raised by it. David indicated he would review Draft 5 for consistency with the changes that were submitted. Voting for sending the LRM to the board needs to be closed by the end of next week and will be held as an email vote as decided previously. 4. Meeting closed