Re: [sv-bc] SV-BC Draft LRM Review Process Per Jan 17 CC

From: Don Mills <drmills98@earthlink.net>
Date: Tue Jan 25 2005 - 23:05:55 PST

I know that I am late, but I got my two chapters reviewed against the change list and found both chapters to have the changes implimented as stated in Mantis. They look GOOD!! Job well done Stu.

Don Mills

Maidment, Matthew R wrote:

>Hi All.
>
>For those SV-BC members who did not attend the Jan 17 SV-BC meeting,
>especially those who were assigned and helped resolved issues for
>the upcoming draft of the LRM I want to explicitly highlight the process
>
>to which the committee has agreed for closing on the review.
>
>(This can also be found in the Jan 17 meeting minutes
>http://www.eda.org/sv-bc/minutes/sv-bc_05_01_17.txt)
>
>
>+Update on LRM Draft & Review Process
>
>The LRM draft is done but needs to be secured prior to distribution.
>Securing & distributing should happen any day. The timeline is for the
>sv-bc to complete its review by Jan 24, end of day. The overall goal
>is to have any issues resolved in time for the Jan 26 P1800 meeting.
>
>The mechanics of the review process are:
>
> Once an issue has status:acknowledged, the appropriate SV-* committee
>
> must review the LRM to ensure that changes for correctness.
> a. If the change is correct, the issue is moved to status:closed
> b. If the change is not correct and the description was correct,
>the
> issue is moved to category:SV-LRM and status:new, and mail is
>sent
> to the LRM team
> c. If the change is not correct and the description of the change
> needs to be modified, the issue is changed to status:assigned
>
>In addition the sv-bc agreed that:
>
> For each sv-bc issue the assignee should be the one to review the LRM
>to
> ensure the change is correct and to update the status accordingly in
>the
> SVDB.
>
> For issues whose changes were determined the sv-bc committee to be
> non-trivial, one or more additional reviewers were identified. The
> additional reviewer(s) will report the status of their review(s) to
>the
> issue assignee. The issue assignee should wait for all of the
>additional
> reviewer(s) before updating the status of their issue(s).
>
> For those assignees who were absent from today's meeting, a secondary
> reviewer was assigned to review and potentially update the status
> in the event the issue assignee is not available. Unless specifically
>
> noted otherwise below, Brad agreed to review issues assigned to Dave
>Rich
> and Nikhil, and Matt agreed to review issues assigned to Doug Warmke.
>
> Here is the list of Issues/Additional Reviewer(s) for Non-Trivial
>Changes
>
> 012 - Dan
> 020 - Dan
> 021 - Steven
> 034 - Dan
> 038 - Brad
> 039 - Dave
> 051 - Francoise
> 074 - Brad
> 076 - Surrendra
> 091 - Dan
> 110 - Steven
> 111 - Brad
> 115 - Mark
> 163 - Brad
> 164 - Dan
> 168 - Kathy, Matt, Steven
> 213 - Brad
> 216 - Brad
> 218 - Steven
> 226 - Steven
> 254 - Surrendra
> 272 - Brad
> 273 - Matt
> 276 - Karen
> 291 - Brad
> 302 - Matt
> 315 - Mark
> 321 - Matt
> 322 - Dan
> 323 - Dan
> 327 - Matt
> 328 - Matt
>
> The sv-bc identified LRM sections relevant to the committee that are
>to
> be reviewed on a more holistic basis by the committee. Below is the
>list
> of relevant sections & corresponding reviewers:
>
> 01/Introduction - Karen
> 02/Literals - Steven
> 03/Data Types - Surrendra
> 04/Arrays - Brad
> 05/Data Declarations - Don
> 07/Operators & Expressions - Francoise
> 08/Statements - Brad
> 10/Tasks & Functions - Brad
> 18/Hierarchy - Kathy
> 19/Interfaces - Karen
> 21/Parameters - Brad
> 22/Configurations - Mark
> 23/System Tasks & Functions - Matt
> 24/VCD - Steven
> 25/Compiler Directives - Don
> Annexes - Brad
>
> The reviewers agreed to send email to reflector by Jan 24
>acknowledging
> completion.
>
>NOTE: Please send mail to the reflector with any issue not logged in the
>SVDB.
>
>Thanks to all of you for your cooperation!
>
>Matt
>--
>Matt Maidment
>mmaidmen@ichips.intel.com
>
>
>

-- 
==========================================================
Don Mills
LCDM Engineering     (Logic, Coding, & Design Methodology) 
mills@lcdm-eng.com                        www.lcdm-eng.com
801-282-6560  Office PHONE      
801-641-5882  Mobile PHONE
4158 W. Ben Armine Cir.,      South Jordan, UT  84095-9101
==========================================================
==========================================================
Don Mills
LCDM Engineering     (Logic, Coding, & Design Methodology) 
mills@lcdm-eng.com                        www.lcdm-eng.com
==========================================================
Received on Tue Jan 25 23:06:01 2005

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.8 : Tue Jan 25 2005 - 23:06:10 PST